I thought the battery-powered toys would be more interesting to our cats. In our house, the simple ones have been much more popular.
The fish wand and catnip mouse were the hits
The cloth fish on a wand was popular with all four girls. So were the SmartyKat Skitter Critters catnip mice—they were super popular.
They seem to enjoy toys they can grab and get their claws into. With the wand, they also get something to chase while I'm involved in the game.
Find the toys
The mice and Christmas wand below are toys we bought. The Dan & Sam fish wand is a similar option we haven’t tested.
The battery-powered toys were a bust
We tried an electric flipping fish and an electric rolling ball with a tail, a bit like a mechanical mouse. Neither was a hit with the girls.
I thought toys with batteries would be more interesting. They move around, they flip, they do things. But that didn't translate into more interest from our cats.
Being part of the game matters
The girls like a chase when I'm involved. A toy moving around by itself hasn't had the same appeal in our house.
That's the distinction I'd pay attention to before buying another gadget: what do the cats actually enjoy doing with it? For ours, grabbing, scratching and chasing something I'm moving have been more popular than watching a toy do its own thing.
Our cats are older
Zette is 14, and the others are around eight. They're not kittens.
I did wonder whether younger cats might find the electronic toys more interesting, but I don't know. This is what happened with our four; I wouldn't put it down to age alone.
What I'd look for next time
For our girls, I'd start with the sort of play they've already enjoyed: something they can get their claws into, or a wand I can use to play with them.
The fish wand and catnip mouse were the hits. The flipping fish and rolling tail ball weren't. That wasn't the result I'd expected when I bought them, but it's the experience I'd use to choose the next toy.

